Diagnosis of human fascioliasis in Arusha region, northern Tanzania by microscopy and clinical manifestations in patients

Background

Human fascioliasis (HF) is a zoonotic disease that has been identified in many countries worldwide. This report concerns the identification and clinical management of cases of human fascioliasis in the suburbs of Arusha city, northern Tanzania in 2013. Fascioliasis is included among the WHO’s Neglected Tropical Diseases as a plant transmitted trematode infection. Human fascioliasis has not been described before in the East Africa region, including Tanzania.

Methods

Patients presenting at a primary healthcare centre in Arusha Region, northern Tanzania provided fresh stool samples for routine ova and parasite screening (saline and iodine preparations). Subsequent stool samples were preserved in 5 % formalin in saline and subjected to ether sedimentation for examination.

Results

Out of 1460 patients, 305 (21 %) were diagnosed positive for fascioliasis based on the demonstration of brownish, oval eggs with inconspicuous opercula in stool. Two distinct egg sizes were identified; large 170–212.5 by 115–150 μm (mean 194.5 by 130.5 μm) and smaller eggs 120–150 by 87.5 – 112.5 μm (mean 138.8 by 101 μm). Clinically, patients presented with fever (39 - 40 °C) and abdominal pain. Some patients had pruritis around the mouth and their lips were swollen. 3 patients were treated and cured with single dose Triclabendazole. The remaining 302 patients were treated with Nitazoxanide and 122 (40 %) were cleared of infection with a single course. Snails of the genus Lymnaea were found in the surroundings.

Conclusions

This report serves to remind medical professionals in East Africa that HF is a probable differential diagnosis in patients presenting with similar symptoms. It is possible to diagnose fascioliasis by light microscopy although specific antigen tests are required for confirmation. Human fascioliasis however, has not been described or reported in Tanzania before and begs further investigation.

Fasciola hepatica and F. gigantica are trematodes commonly referred to as the liver flukes in sheep, goats and cattle where they cause serious disease with significant economic losses to farmers. Humans become infected with the Fasciola by ingesting metacercariae encysted on leaves of vegetables including watercress, radishes, corn, spinach, alfalfa and broccoli [1]. Humans can also become infected with Fasciola metacercariae in water when drunk. Adult liver flukes are found in the bile ducts and liver parenchyma of infected human and animal hosts. Fasciola cannot be passed directly from one person to another [2]. Eggs passed in stool of infected hosts hatch into miracidia which need freshwater lymnaeid snail vectors to develop to sporocysts, rediae and cercariae which leave the snail intermediate host and encyst on leaves of vegetation as the infective metacercariae [1–3]. After ingestion, juvenile flukes are released from the metacercariae in the small intestine, having survived stomach acid digestion. They penetrate the intestinal wall and migrate through the abdominal cavity, the liver capsule and into the liver parenchyma. Following the penetration of the capsule the immature flukes migrate through the liver tissues for about 6–8 weeks in the case of F. hepatica and up to 12–14 weeks for F. gigantica, finally entering the bile ducts where they mature and begin egg production [3, 4].

Human fascioliasis (HF) is usually asymptomatic, though symptoms may occur early on in the infection when immature flukes migrate from the intestine through the abdominal cavity and liver. Symptoms associated with HF are generally non-specific and can be categorized as acute and chronic. Symptoms of the acute disease can start 4 to 7 days after infection characterized by fever, nausea, malaise and abdominal pain. Less often patients may present with urticaria as well as subcutaneous nodules [3, 4]. The chronic phase of the infection occurs much later, usually 12 to 16 weeks after infection, when adult flukes have settled in the bile ducts. On clinical examination a tender or non-tender hepatomegaly may be found. The symptoms of chronic disease may last for months to years after infection, usually resulting from inflammation and blockage of bile ducts. This is usually complicated by biliary colic, cholestasis or cholangitis in untreated patients [5, 6].

The rather distinct and rare ova in stool samples of various patients visiting TotalCare Medical Centre was first noticed in April 2012. At the time, it was a rather common finding to have high infection rates of Ancylostoma duodenale, Giardia lamblia as well as Entamoeba histolytica in stool samples examined for parasitic infections. By mid-September 2012, many patients presented with clinical symptoms suggestive of typhoid fever or intestinal worm infections. When stool from these patients was examined microscopically, eggs with unfamiliar brownish, oval appearance and inconspicuous operculum were observed; this was usually accompanied by supporting biochemical and serological findings, where analyzed.

Studies conducted within the northern Africa region showed the epidemiological picture of human fascioliasis to have changed in recent years. The number of reports of humans infected with fascioliasis has increased significantly since the 1980s and several geographical areas have been described as endemic for the disease in humans [2, 4–13].

Literature cited on HF in Africa showed that both prevalence and intensity of infection were significantly higher among girls than boys, with the highest prevalence and intensity of infection being reported in the 9–11 years age group. Women were more affected than men, but not at a significant level [9–11]. Many Fasciola infected children were also co-infected by other parasites [10–12]. The clinical diagnosis of fascioliasis depends largely on the microscopic examination of stool samples for ova by finding eggs with an inconspicuous operculum [1, 3, 5]. Specific coprologic antigen tests have recently been developed to determine the species of Fasciola in clinical and field studies [12–15]. Immunodiagnostic techniques using recombinant Fasciola hepatica cathepsin L 1cystine proteinase, purified cathepsin L cystine proteinase, and cathepsin L-ELISA have been used to diagnose HF especially in the pre-patent acute phase of disease [13–17]. In human infection the drug of choice is Triclabendazole because it has been noted to have the highest efficacy against both the migratory juvenile and adult stages. In many areas with scarce supply of Triclabendazole, Nitazoxanide has also been used with differing success [18]. By mid- September 2012, many patients presented with clinical symptoms suggestive of fascioliasis. Tanzania and East Africa at large have also had various reports on animal fascioliasis and its management [19].

This report concerns the clinical and parasitological findings of cases of HF at TotalCare Medical Centre, a private, primary healthcare facility located in Themi Hill, Arusha region, Tanzania. Consequent to various treatment attempts with Nitazoxanide, as of October 2013, many re-infections occurred. These cases were rather evenly spread demographically including age, sex, social-economic background and race of people living in the Themi Hill surroundings, which has a notably high, seasonal population of various snail species, particularly of the family Lymnaeidea.

Many local inhabitants of the area use man-made deep water wells and natural streams as a source of water for domestic consumption. During the seasonal rains, the area is subject to flooding and soggy, marshy soils especially towards the lower lying residential areas.

Ethical approval

This study was approved in July of 2012 by the health management team of TotalCare Medical Centre as an in-house clinical case study. In the conduct of this study, compliance to good clinical practice as defined by the Helsinki Declaration was observed. All subjects involved provided written informed consent. Children’s parents offered the consent on behalf of their children as expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki.

Clinical

Most patients presenting at the clinic complained mainly of high grade fever (39 - 40 °C), abdominal pain at the upper right quadrant area and malaise. No abnormality was detected on abdominal examination. Few of these patients also presented with complaints of pruritis around the mouth with swelling of the lips. Jaundice was also observed. In clinical practice such presentation would range from malaria, typhoid fever to urinary tract infection (UTI). Laboratory investigations commonly ordered were blood smear for malaria parasites, Widal test for typhoid fever and urinalysis. Patients were provided with stool containers containing 5 % formalin diluted in saline as a preservative.

Clinical management

The clinical management of patients in the beginning of this study was punctuated by apparent uncertainty and lack of conclusive laboratory diagnosis of human fascioliasis in our setting. Nevertheless, following a cautious approach and exhaustive research on fascioliasis, we came up with a reliable management protocol for patients diagnosed with human fascioliasis.

Three of the 305 patients were treated with Triclabendazole administered at 10–12 mg/kg, which cleared the patients of Fasciola infection. The remaining 302 were treated with Nitazoxanide at a dose of 500 mg twice daily for 6 days in adults and 200 mg twice daily for 3 days in children older than 4 years. Only 125 patients were cleared of infection.

Laboratory diagnosis

Patients presenting at the outpatient department (OPD) were asked to provide a stool sample on day 1, 3 and 6 for the qualitative diagnosis of parasite infection. Sample collection and processing protocol was as recommended by Cheesbrough [20]. Briefly, for fresh samples stool in a clear transparent container was processed within 30 min of collection. A plastic scoop provided with the stool container was used to sample the edges and core of the specimen, collecting approximately 0.5 gm of feces. This was mixed to homogeneity in 10 microlitre saline on a glass slide. A drop of 1 % iodine was placed on the homogenized fecal preparation and a coverslip applied. Iodized preparations were quickly examined under the light microscope for identification of parasite eggs/ova at ×100 and ×400 magnification.

Subsequently, patients who received anthelminthic treatment were provided with 50 ml stool containers containing 5 ml of 5 % formalin diluted in saline as a preservative. They were instructed on how to collect the stool sample, typically a scoop full or approximately 5gm to be mixed with the preservative and the cover sealed tight. The sample was then brought to the laboratory the following day. This protocol was routinely followed and proved to be useful when patients were treated with anthelminthics to assess effect of treatment.

Briefly, the stool was mixed to homogeneity in the preservative (5 % formalin in saline). Ether (2 ml) was then added to the homogenate and mixed thoroughly. The mixture was then left to stand for 20 min before a sample of the sediment and the supernatant was collected for examination. Approximately 0.02 ml sample was placed at the centre of a microscope slide and a drop of iodine added. A cover slip was placed over the mixture, and the slide examined at x100 and x400 magnification.

A graduated reticle inserted in the objective piece was first calibrated against the stage micrometer for standardization. Egg size estimations were then made at ×100 magnification, and pictures taken at ×400 magnification for clarity of features.

Repeat stool samples were taken day 3, 6, 14 and 21 post-therapy to screen for the presence of ova or parasites. When a diagnosis of fascioliasis was tentatively reached, all samples suspected to have eggs were stored at 2-8 °C and transported to the reference laboratory at the Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College for confirmation of the diagnosis. In cases of mixed infections, patients were first managed for other infections. Examination of stools for earlier suspected Fasciola eggs was started after confirmation of treatment for co-infections. This served as a further quality control method for the diagnosis arrived at.

The data was then analyzed using descriptive statistics.

The majority of patients attending the clinic (96 %) were from the Themi-Njiro area (living within 2-10 km of the clinic), in Arusha municipality, Tanzania. A few patients also came from other municipalities outside Arusha. Children below 12 years were the most often diagnosed with fascioliasis (45 %).

Blood smears were mostly negative for haemo-parasites, including malaria, but showed eosinophilia. The Widal test for typhoid fever was positive in some patients with titres of 1:160. Urinalysis was negative for bacterial infection but showed moderate bilirubinuria. Stool examination showed presence of oval Fasciola eggs along with Ancylostoma duodenale eggs or Strongyloides stercoralislarvae. Most of these were treated with Albendazole and effect of treatment was observed for 2 weeks after completion of medication. During this treatment period though, patients who had initially presented with urticaria worsened.

Oval Fasciola eggs (Figure 1) were demonstrated in 305 out of 1460 stool specimens. We reviewed 50 samples fixed in 5 % formalin in saline and stored for 1 week at 2-8 °C. Two distinct egg size patterns were noted; large ovoid eggs 170–212.5 by 115–150 μm (mean 194.5 by 130.5 μm) and a smaller egg range of 120–150 by 87.5 – 112.5 μm (mean 138.8 by 101 μm).

a and b Eggs of Fasciola (a, small size; 130.5 by 102 μm and b, large 205 by 148 μm) as seen in an iodine stained stool sample after formol-ether sedimentation. Original magnification x400 (arrow indicates position of the inconspicuous operculum; bar scale = 50 μm and 75 μm)

Full size image

A snail of the genus Lymnaea, found in a natural water source around the study area is presented in Fig. 2. Sex and age distribution of the patients diagnosed with fascioliasis and the annual distribution of cases diagnosed at TotalCare Medical Centre are shown in Figs. 3 and 4 respectively.

A snail of the genus Lymnaea, one of the snails which act as intermediate host of Fasciola on a piece of vegetation from a natural stream

Full size image

Frequency of occurrence of fascioliasis in males and females stratified from 1 to 11 years based on stool examination

Full size image

Frequency of diagnosis of fascioliasis in males and females of all age groups from September 2012 to October 2013

Full size image

The results of stool examination for Fasciola eggs before and after treatment as well as re-infection after treatment are given (see Flow Chart). 305 samples out of 1460 tested positive for Fasciola eggs in stool. Out of these 103 (34 %) were males and 202 (66 %) were females. 138 (45 %) were below 12 years old. All 3 patients treated with Triclabendazole were cured. 134 patients out of 302 returned for stool examination within a two week period after treatment with Nitazoxanide; 83 (62 %) of these were below the age of 12 years (data not shown); 122 patients were cleared of infection with single dose Nitazoxanide of whom 67 (55 %) were below 12 years old. 36 patients out of the 302 treated with Nitazoxanide manifested severe reaction to the drug which necessitated discontinuation; 25 (69 %) of these were female with only 8 (22 %) below 12 years (data not presented in the chart). After successful treatment confirmed by re-examination of stool samples for eggs over a 2 week period, 42 of the original 305 patients were re-infected with Fasciola at varying time intervals during the study period (12 months); 29 (69 %) of these 42 patients were children in the high risk age group i.e. below 12 years (data not shown).

Showing Results of stool examination of 1460 stool samples for Fasciola eggs (pre- and post- treatment and effect of treatment). *Side effects of Nitazoxanide were noticed more frequently and severely among females than males (data not shown). All patients presented with abdominal pain (day 2–4), diarrhea (day 2–3), pharyngitis and flu-like syndrome (day 2–6) of treatment. In a few patients with pruritis, swelling and rashes of hands and feet was observed

Full size image

Other laboratory procedures performed and data analysis are presented in Table 1 and Table 2 below . They included urinalysis, blood sugar, liver enzymes and cell blood count. The comment column represents significant findings

Animal fascioliasis is a liver disease of ruminants which has been described in many parts of the world including a few African countries [1–5, 7–12]. Recently, human fascioliasis has also been described as a zoonosis acquired from domestic animals. Human fascioliasis is acquired by the ingestion of Fasciola metacercariae encysted on vegetables or in drinking water. The distribution of human fascioliasis has recently been reported in four African countries including; Egypt, Ethiopia, Cameroon and South Africa. In most rural African settings, domestic animals including cattle, sheep and goats are part of agricultural activities, for provision of meat, milk and hide. Similarly, in these settings, vegetables including lettuce, radishes, corncob, alfalfa, and amaranths are cultivated to provide vegetable food source. Rural and semi - rural African settings readily provide the environment suitable for the completion of the life cycle of animal fascioliasis, which includes infected animals that would release infective eggs into the environment and the subsequent development of cercariae within Lymnaea snails, up to development of metacercaria which encyst on vegetable leaves. When human and animal fascioliasis concur the transmission cycle of fascioliasis is amplified many fold.

The suburbs of Arusha city, where this study was conducted, provide a scenario described above for efficient transmission of animal fascioliasis to humans, i.e. the agricultural system in this area includes cattle, sheep and goats and vegetables are cultivated in abundance as an additional food source. Additionally, some of the inhabitants drink untreated water from natural streams.

In our case series, which involved 1460 persons over a 12 month period, 305 (21 %) were found to be infected with fascioliasis. Because Fasciola eggs are not detected during the acute infection, and because the disease has not been described before in Tanzania, it is likely that laboratory investigations intended to detect intestinal worm infections in stool would have missed the recognition of Fasciola eggs in the stool samples.

We also observed two distinct egg sizes on microscopic examination: large ovoid eggs mean 194.5 by 130.5 μm and smaller oval eggs mean 138.8 by 101 μm, which correspond to reported egg size ranges for fasciolid eggs [1, 5]. The eggs recovered in this study are notably wider than reported egg size ranges for both F. hepatica and F. gigantica from other reports [1, 21]. This could be due to preservation in 5 % formalin in saline (for 1 week) before measurements were taken. It could also be a slight variation is egg size for this region as no previous studies have reported the infection characteristics among humans, and egg sizes have been noted to vary according to geographical location [1, 5, 21]. The presence of two distinct egg sizes, sometimes recovered from stool samples of the same patient also point to possible co-infection by the different species, and may further insinuate the possibility of hybrid species [21, 22]. Although we were unable to speciate the causative parasite as being Fasciola hepatica or F. gigantica in this particular clinical study, other veterinary and malacology studies conducted in the region and East Africa in general [19, 22, 23] have shown the presence of both species. The climatic and demographic distribution of the two species has been highlighted [21–23] and of note is the presence of both species in certain geographical regions, subject to altitude and fresh water availability. Because Fasciola eggs have an inconspicuous operculum, it is difficult for the unsuspecting investigator to identify them with certainty, even in well documented endemic regions [1–3, 5–8].

Triclabendazole is the drug of choice for the treatment of both animal and human fascioliasis as noted in other studies [12, 18]. In this study, three patients were cleared of HF by a single dose of this drug. Use of Nitazoxanide did not clear all patients treated. This finding was consistent with some earlier reports.

This study has shown that more females than males are infected with HF and that fascioliasis is quite often associated with children below 12 years in both sexes. This finding is in agreement with what has been previously reported about the epidemiology of HF in some African and tropical countries [4, 6, 8–11]. The reasons for sex and age bias for HF could be because, at least in our settings, young girls and boys are culturally engaged as drawers of domestic water for house hold use. This practice would expose them more frequently to infection with HF than would adults. At TotalCare Medical Centre, records also indicated that there were more women and young children who visited the health centre than adult males.

Laboratory investigations including bilirubin levels indicated elevated serum and urinary bilirubin which is in agreement with findings by other studies on HF [7, 24]. Examination of blood films showed that most patients had marked eosinophilia, which is also of value in the diagnosis of HF during the acute phase of the disease [24]. Clinically, fascioliasis patients present with fever and malaise, urticaria and swelling of lips during the acute stage of disease. In this study, pain at the upper right abdominal quadrant was a common clinical finding in most of the patients whose stools were found positive for Fasciola eggs. Pruritis was also reported by some of the patients and swelling of the lips was also seen. The latter three findings have also been described by other studies [7] as common findings associated with HF in the chronic, patent phase of the disease.

The challenges associated with a definitive diagnosis of human fascioliasis, especially at the clinical level are many: First, eggs are never passed in stool during the acute phase of the disease, therefore patients presenting clinically are likely to be missed on routine stool screening especially if only a single sample is examined without concentration. Clinical symptoms are also usually less pronounced in subsequent infections [3, 5, 24]. Much of the symptomatology presented in this study was further confounded by other infections diagnosed and cannot definitively be attributed to fascioliasis, even where eggs were found in patients’ stools.

Secondly, although we examined at least 2 samples per patient, we used only a qualitative concentration/sedimentation method as these screenings were not prejudiced towards the detection of Fasciola eggs alone. No quantification was done nor were any methods employed for the purpose. Other intestinal parasites were often diagnosed and consequently managed before specific screening for fascioliasis was started. Lastly, the definitive diagnosis of fascioliasis by species is usually based on the use of specific coprologic antigen tests or molecular analysis [11–15]. This study was conducted in-house in a primary health centre where neither of these diagnostic options were available, nor have they been approved for use in the country and region to date. Human fascioliasis has not been hitherto reported from Tanzania or any other East African country. Subsequent studies could focus on this distinction and make further clinical associations once the disease has been recognized as a significant public health problem.

This study serves as a reminder to the medical profession in East Africa that HF, a food borne trematode infection, is probably of more common occurrence than has hitherto been realized.

ALT:

Alanine transaminase

AST:

Aspartate amino tranferase

ELISA:

Enzyme linked immune-sorbent assay

fL:

femtolitres

g/dL:

gram per decilitre

Hb:

Haemoglobin

HF:

Human fascioliasis

MCH:

Mean corpuscular haemoglobin

MCHC:

Mean corpuscular haemoglobin concentration

MEPI:

Medical Education Partnership Initiative

MCV:

Mean corpuscular volume

mg:

milligram

NTD:

Neglected tropical disease

OPD:

out patient department

UTI:

Urinary tract infection

U/L:

unit per litre

We would like to acknowledge the support we received from the administration and staff at TotalCare Medical Centre in Njiro, Arusha; we especially acknowledge Focas Lukas Matawa and Esther Wairimu Kabare, who together with ASL constituted the lab team on this study. Lucy Mimano and Pius Tarimo at the MEPI-Wet Lab of Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College gave valued support in confirmation of Fasciola eggs in human stool samples.

Affiliations

1. Department of Medical Parasitology and Entomology, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College, P.O. Box 2240, Moshi, Tanzania

   • Abdul-Hamid Settenda Lukambagire
   •  & Mramba Nyindo

2. Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, P.O. Box 3010, Moshi, Tanzania

   • Deborah N. Mchaile

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Abdul-Hamid Settenda Lukambagire.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests. This study received no funding from conception to publication. Routine tests done were part of the usual clinical management procedure and related expenses were met by the patients. A fee reduction was graciously approved by the clinic administration for follow-up stool analysis done on enrolled patients throughout the study period.

Authors’ contributions

ASL conceptualized and designed the study, conducted the laboratory tests and field surveys. DNM conducted all the clinical management and follow up of patients. MN provided expert consultation and oversaw the quality assurance at the referral laboratory. ALL three authors contributed equally to the manuscript formulation.

Reprints and Permissions