Epidemiological and clinical features of rotavirus among children younger than 5 years of age hospitalized with acute gastroenteritis in Northern Italy

Background

Rotavirus is the major cause of acute gastroenteritis and severe dehydrating diarrhea in young children.

Methods

To estimate the proportion of hospital admissions for rotavirus acute gastroenteritis and identify the circulating G and P genotypes among children under five years of age, we conducted a prospective observational study from January to December 2008, recruiting children consecutively admitted to six hospitals in Milan and nearby towns in northern Italy. Typing was done on stool samples by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction amplification.

Results

Of the 521 stool samples from children with acute gastroenteritis, 34.9% (95%CI, 30.8 to 39.2%) were rotavirus-positive. Two thirds (67.6%) were under two years of age, and 13.2% were under six months. The predominant G type was G1 (40.7%), followed by G9 (22.5%), G2 (13.2%), G3 (5.5%), G4 (3.8%) and G10 (1.6%). Twenty-one (11.7%) mixed-G infections were identified: G1+G10 (8.8%); G1+G9 (1.6%); and G2+G10 (1.2%). Only P[8] (67.6%) and P[4] (12.6%) types were P genotyped. The predominant single G/P combination was G1P[8] (39.7%), followed by G9P[8] (25.3%), G2P[4] (14.3%), and G3P[8] (4.1%). All G-mixed types combined with P[8].

Conclusions

These findings show an high prevalence of rotavirus infections among children admitted to hospital for acute gastroenteritis caused by different rotavirus strains circulating in the area studied.

Rotavirus is the most common cause of acute gastroenteritis and the leading cause of severe dehydrating diarrhea in infants and young children [1]. In Europe, every child is expected to experience episodes of gastroenteritis during the first three years of life [2]. A recent study [3] estimated that there are 3.6 million episodes of rotavirus disease annually among the 23.6 million children under the age of five, living in the European Union, with 231 deaths, more than 87,000 hospitalizations and about 700,000 primary care consultations. In the USA, rotavirus causes an estimated 410,000 medical consultations, more than 200,000 emergency visits, and about 50,000-70,000 hospital admissions per year [4–7].

The admission rate for children with gastroenteritis has not declined in recent years, and may even have risen [6]. The costs of rotavirus gastroenteritis contribute to a critical burden of disease in the pediatric population [8, 9]. A recent update of the global burden of rotavirus disease put the median cost of hospital stay in EU-25 Member States at about €1,417 [9].

Rotavirus is composed by 11 double-stranded RNA segments surrounded by three concentric protein layers. The outer capsid consists of VP7 (a glycoprotein) and VP4 (a protease-sensitive protein) which carry independent neutralization and protective antigens. A binary system of rotavirus classification has been established to designate the neutralization specificity of the VP7 and VP4 proteins. The VP7 serotype is known as G and the VP4 serotype as P.

Vaccination has been suggested as a public health strategy to prevent rotavirus infection and reduce the burden of disease [10]. Rotavirus vaccine was recommended for routine use among young children in the USA in 2006. Currently, the World Health Organization recommends including rotavirus vaccines in national immunization programs in regions where the efficacy data suggest a significant public health impact and where appropriate infrastructure and financing resources are available [11]. In Europe, rotavirus gastroenteritis can now be prevented by vaccination with two vaccines (RotaTeq^®, Merck & Co. Inc, Whitehouse Station, NJ; Rotarix^®, GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Rixensart, Belgium) licensed in 2006. In Italy, no data exists currently about vaccination coverage.

Accurate information on the burden of rotavirus gastroenteritis are crucial to guide recommendations for rotavirus vaccination [12], most epidemiological data have been based on retrospective data. Thus, as the distribution of circulating rotavirus serotypes may vary dynamically, prospective studies are needed to help the health authorities in planning effective immunization strategies, and for industry to look into the possibilities for new up-to-date rotavirus vaccines.

The main aim of this study was to estimate the proportion of rotavirus gastroenteritis and identify the distribution of circulating G and P genotype rotavirus strains among children under five years of age living in the metropolitan area of Milan, northern Italy, and admitted to hospital with acute gastroenteritis. We also examined the relationship between rotavirus genotype and the clinical characteristics of gastroenteritis.

This prospective, multicenter, observational study was conducted over a 12-month period, and involved six hospitals in Milan and nearby towns. All children under five years of age at admission and admitted to hospital between 1 January and 31 December 2008 were assessed for eligibility. Inclusion criterion was acute gastroenteritis at enrolment. The exclusion criteria were refusal to give written consent and a previous rotavirus vaccination. Acute gastroenteritis was defined as three or more loose stools per day for less than 14 days at enrolment [13].

The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and Good Clinical Practice guidelines. The ethics committee of each hospital reviewed and approved the study protocol. Written informed consent was obtained from the parents or legal guardians at enrolment. No incentive was provided to encourage study participation.

At enrolment, each child was visited by experienced pediatricians (two per center), and underwent a scheduled medical examination including routine assessments.

The pediatricians attended a one-day training course for standardization during the week before starting the study. The pediatricians also interviewed the parents or the legal guardian to collect socio-demographic data, medical history and clinical characteristics of the current episode of acute gastroenteritis.

A stool sample was taken within 18 hours of admission for each child. Approximately 5 g of stool was collected, immediately stored at -20°C, and shipped frozen to the Department of Public Health-Microbiology-Virology of the University of Milan, for analysis. Stool samples were tested for VP6 rotavirus antigen by immuno-chromatographic assay (Orion Diagnostica Inc., Espoo, Finland), according to the manufacturer's instructions. Viral RNA was extracted from 10% fecal suspension using QIAamp MinElute Virus Spin (Qiagen GmBH., Hilden Germany) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The extracted viral RNA was stored at -70°C until testing. Rotavirus RNA was detected by hemi-nested reverse polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) employing type-specific primers.

In the first round, a 881 nt fragment of the VP7 region was amplified with generic primers VP7F and VP7R [14]. The G genotypes was subsequently determined on amplicons obtained using a pool of internal primers specific for G1-G4 and G8-G10 rotavirus genotypes in combination with the appropriate reverse consensus primers [14]. Similarly, a 663 nt fragment of the VP4 region was reverse transcribed and amplified using the generic primers VP4F and VP4R, and P genotyping was done using internal primers specific for P[4], P[6], P[8], P[9], P[10] and P[11][15]. Lastly, the amplicons were analyzed by electrophoresis using a 2% agarose gel at 100 V for 60 minutes.

Diarrhea, dehydration status, body rectal temperature, vomiting, and behavioral symptoms (i.e., irritability, lethargy, seizure) were monitored during the hospital stay. Diarrhea was defined in accordance with the International Classification of Diseases (ICD)-9 code 787.91, and vomiting included ICD-9 codes 787.01 and 787.03. Dehydration status was recorded using the accepted reference standard of the 'percentage of volume lost' calculated as the difference between the rehydration weight (post-rehydration body weight) and the acute weight (body weight at presentation) divided by the rehydration weight [16]. Dehydration severity was classified in accordance with the European Society of Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition [17] in three categories, with body weight loss < 5%, 5-10%, >10%. The 20-point Ruuska-Vesikari scale [18] was used as a further overall indicator of the severity of acute gastroenteritis. This scale assigns points according to duration and intensity of diarrhea, vomiting, body temperature, behavioral symptoms, and the treatment given. Ruuska-Vesikari defines severity of disease as: mild, score ≤6; moderate, score 7-10; severe, score ≥11.

Statistical analysis

The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used to assess normality of distribution of the variables. All variables except age were not symmetrically distributed (P < 0.05). Descriptive data for age are reported as mean and standard deviation (SD). For the other variables we report the median (range) or number of observations (percentage). The proportion of rotavirus gastroenteritis among all the hospital admissions for acute gastroenteritis was calculated with the exact binomial 95% confidence interval (CI). Comparisons of age for the rotavirus genotypes were tested by one-way ANOVA. Comparisons of rotavirus genotypes for non-symmetric variables were done the Kruskal-Wallis test, followed by the non-parametric multiple comparisons Tukey's test. A P-value < 0.05 was considered to indicate statistical significance (two-tailed test). All statistical analyses were done using the SPSS software, version 15.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL).

A total of 638 children aged less than 5 years were admitted with acute gastroenteritis (374 boys, 264 girls; mean [±SD] age 1.5 ±1.3 years). Stool samples were tested to 521 (81.7%) children: 182 (110 boys, 72 girls; mean age 1.7 ± 1.1 years) were positive for rotavirus, namely 34.9% (95%CI, 30.8-39.2%). There were 123 cases of rotavirus gastroenteritis in children under two years old (67.6%): 24 (13.2%) in infants aged < 6 months; 37 (20.3%) in infants aged 6 to < 12 months; and 62 (34.1%) in infants aged 1 to < 2 years.

Severe acute gastroenteritis occurred in 126 (69.2%) rotavirus-positive children and in 140 (41.4%) rotavirus-negative children (P < 0.0001), with no difference between groups in duration of hospital stay (median and range 4 (1-10) vs. 4 (1-9) days) (P = 0.718).

Admissions for rotavirus gastroenteritis showed seasonal differences (P < 0.001), with more cases in spring (85; 46.7%) and winter (74; 40.7%) than autumn (19; 10.4%) and summer (4; 2.2%) (Figure 1). All G types were observed both in winter and spring. The four cases occurring in summer were one single G1, one single G9 and two G1+G10. Among cases occurring in autumn 18 were G1 (12 G1 alone, and 6 G1+G10) and one G3. Figure 2 shows the distribution of the typed rotavirus G genotypes over the year.

Number of admissions for acute rotavirus gastroenteritis by month, in the area of Milan, northern Italy (%).

Full size image

Number of typed rotavirus G genotypes by month, in the area of Milan, northern Italy.

Full size image

Among the 182 rotavirus-positive cases, 180 (98.9%) were identified for G genotype and 146 (80.2%) for P genotype (Table 1). One case (girl, age 3 months) was neither G nor P genotyped. Single G types were observed in 159 (87.4%) cases, mixed-G types in 21 (11.5%). G1 (74, 40.7%) was the predominant single rotavirus G type, followed by G9 (41, 22.5%), G2 (24, 13.2%), G3 (10, 5.5%), G4 (7, 3.8%) and G10 (3, 1.6%). Mixed-G types were identified as G1+G10 (16, 8.9%), G1+G9 (3, 1.6%) and G2+G10 (2, 1.1%). Only P[8] (123, 67.6%) and P[4] (23, 12.6%) types were found. In 146 cases genotyped for both G and P, the predominant combination was G1P[8] (58, 39.7%), followed by G9P[8] (37, 25.3%) and G2P[4] (21, 14.3%). Each mixed-G type combined with P[8].

The rotavirus gastroenteritis was rated as mild, moderate or severe in 12 (6.6%), 44 (24.2%) and 126 (69.2%) children, respectively (Ruuska-Vesikari scale). Dehydration was < 5%, 5-10%, > 10%, in 158 (86.7%), 22 (12.2%), and 2 (1.1%) children (one girl aged 20 months with G3P[4], and one girl aged 47 months with G2P[4]). The median (range) duration of diarrhea was 5 (1-11) days. The median (range) maximum rectal temperature was 38.8°C (36.6-40.4). Vomiting occurred in 164 (90.1%) children and 133 (73.1%) presented behavioral symptoms. Oral rehydration was required for 129 (70.9%) children, intravenous rehydration for 138 (75.8%).

Table 2 summarizes the main clinical characteristics of the rotavirus gastroenteritis, according to G and P genotypes. Duration (median, range) of diarrhea was shorter in G3 (3, 2-4 days) than in G1 (5, 1-10 days) and G9 (5, 2-10 days) (both P < 0.05). Duration of diarrhea was associated with severity of gastroenteritis (Spearman correlation coefficient, r = 0.423, P < 0.0001), percentage of dehydration (r = 0.168, P = 0.023) and duration of hospital stay (r = 0.554, P < 0.0001), and was longer in younger children (r = -0.155, P < 0.0001). Maximum rectal temperature was lower in G1+G10 than in G3 (39.6°C, 36.8-40.4) (P < 0.01). Dehydration differed among G subtypes (P < 0.001) and was higher in G1 (1.8, 0-10%) and G3 (1.9, 0-10.9%) than G9 (0, 0-8.2%) (P < 0.01) but the differences between G genotypes were not significant for severity of dehydration (P > 0.287). Similarly, the differences between G genotypes were not significant for Ruuska-Vesikari scores (P = 0.610), number of days with vomiting (P = 0.328), or behavioral symptoms (P = 0.417). There were no significant differences between P genotypes for any of the clinical characteristics (minimum P = 0.09 for duration of diarrhea).

Mean age and sex distribution did not differ for G or P genotypes (minimum P > 0.167). Duration of hospital stay did not differ among G types (P = 0.250), ranging from a median (range) of 3 (3-5) days with G10 to 7 (4-10) days with G2+G10. Median (range) hospital stay was respectively 5 (1-9) days and 4.5 (2-8) days in the P[8] and P[4] subgroups, and did not differ with the P non-typeable (36) cases (median 5, range 2-11 days) (P > 685).

Continuous monitoring of rotavirus genotype distribution would be valuable to show up the diversity and changes in the circulating strains that may be more important than ever since the introduction of rotavirus vaccination. Updating epidemiological data and extending knowledge worldwide might prove useful for designing up-to-date vaccine-based prevention strategies.

The present study is the first to provide information on rotavirus distribution in northern Italy. It prospectively investigated the rotavirus genotype distribution among children under five years of age living in the metropolitan area of Milan admitted to hospital for acute gastroenteritis. It also looked into possible relations between the clinical characteristics of disease and the rotavirus genotype.

The findings confirmed that rotavirus is a major cause of hospitalization for acute gastroenteritis among children under five years of age, accounting for 34.9% of cases. In Europe, it was estimated that in the period 2004-2005 about 10.4% to 36.0% of children aged five years or younger and admitted with acute gastroenteritis had disease caused by rotavirus [19]. More recently, in a prospective study conducted in five European Union countries (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom) in children aged < 5 years, rotavirus accounted for 56.2% of all hospitalized community-acquired acute gastroenteritis cases, ranging from 33.2% in Italy to 64.4% in France [20]. There also appears to be a substantial burden of rotavirus hospitalization among young children in the United States, [6, 7, 21, 22] with rotavirus accounting for about 18.4% of annual hospital admissions for acute gastroenteritis among children < 0.5 years of age [6].

In our study, most admissions for acute rotavirus gastroenteritis were infants, with 13.2% aged less than six months, and two among the very youngest (less than two months old). These figures are slightly lower than recent European surveillance data showing that rotavirus gastroenteritis ranged from 56.7% to 74.2% of cases of acute gastroenteritis in infants aged 6 to 23 months, and from 18.1% to 31.9% in infants aged < 6 months [23].

The present study found a clear seasonal pattern of acute rotavirus gastroenteritis that peaked in winter and early spring, with only 2.2% of cases in summer. It is conceivable that when there is a seasonal pattern children may become infected at later ages, because they have not been continuously exposed to the virus [24]. Indeed, seasonality of rotavirus has been observed in different parts of the world; thus, it would be better for future studies to analyse samples from a "season" rather than a "calendar year".

G1 was the predominant rotavirus G type, found in 51.1% of cases (40.7% alone; 10.4% in mixtures), and collectively with G9 (22.5% alone; 1.6% in mixtures) and G2 (13.2% alone; 1.1% in mixtures) it accounted for more than 90% of the rotavirus strains identified. In an extensive review published in 2005 Santos and Hoshino [25] merged a total of 45571 cases collected worldwide from 124 studies, and estimated that G1, G2, G3 and G4 covered about 90% of rotavirus G types. In the present study we found a higher proportion of G9 than the 7.4% reported by De Donno et al. [26], 2.2%-11.1% by Tcheremenskaia [27] (except in Bulgaria where the rate of G9 was 36.6%), and 1.3-9.6% by Santos et al. [25]; however, our data compares well with a recent European study [20] that found G9 (31.2%) was the second most prevalent circulating rotavirus G type after G1 (40.3%). In the present study the prevalence of G3 was comparable with previous reports [20, 25] while circulation of G4 was lower.

Geographic and temporal differences in rotavirus genotype distribution may explain at least some of these differences, as has been pointed out in several studies worldwide [20, 25, 28, 29]. Recognition of G10 alone confirms the presence of this rotavirus genotype in Italy and in other European countries, as reported recently [26, 27]. As a matter of fact, the prevalence (10%) of G10 mixed-G types is higher than previously reported. However it would be important to underline that 83.3% (15/18) of patients with such genotypes were admitted to the same hospital in a restricted period of time (September-December).

Epidemiological surveys showed that this genotype may be detected in increasing proportions of infants and young children with acute gastroenteritis in parts of India [30], Brazil [31], Paraguay [32], and Thailand [33]. Although interspecies transmission of animal rotavirus to humans appears to be a very rare event, the introduction of certain animal rotavirus genes into human rotaviruses through genetic reassortment appears to be common, as in the case of G10 [25].

Lastly, in the present study the proportion of G-mixed types was in the found previously, ranging from about 1.6% to 12.7%.

Among P genotypes, P[8] and P[4] accounted for all P typed cases. The predominant combinations were G1P[8] (44.1%), G9P[8] (35.6%), G4P[8] (5.1%) and G3P[8] (3.4%). A similar distribution was found in Europe recently by Forster et al. [20], with G1P[8], 40.3%; G9P[8], 31.2%; G4P[8], 13.5%; and G3P[8], 7.1%). Other reports show G1P[8], G9P[8], G4P[8], G3P[8], and G2P[4] as collectively responsible for more than 90% of the rotavirus infections in Western countries, about 70% in South America and Asia, and 50% in Africa [25]. The importance of G9P[8] in Italy was pointed out by De Donno et al. [26]. This type was relatively common in South America (15%), Asia (22% in Bangladesh between 2000 and 2006 [34], 8.5% in India between 2005-2007 [35], 33.8% and 54.8% in 2001 and 2002 in Taiwan [36]) and Africa (15% in Nigeria in 2006 [37]), and possibly less frequent in the United States where a recent ten-year pre-vaccine surveillance (1996 to 2005) estimated the overall rate at 3.6%, but it has now really risen to 31% in Europe [20].

Some caution is needed, however, in interpreting the findings of the present study concerning the P genotype because of the fairly large proportion (19.8%) of P non-typeable samples. While this proportion is lower than in some other studies (e.g. 38.6% in [32]), Forster et al. [20] managed to genotype all samples. Since rotaviruses genetically mutate (sequential point mutations, genetic reassortment, genomic rearrangement or intragenic recombination) [38, 39], it is to be expected that sometimes today's RT-PCR methodologies are unable to identify all types. Unusual G/P combinations have been described worldwide and may amount globally to about 5% of all rotavirus types. The appearance of new strains may reflect naturally occurring reassortants among various human rotavirus genotypes but might also involve reassortants between human and animal strains and/or result from direct transmission from animals to humans [40].

As regards how the rotavirus genotype was related to the clinical features of acute gastroenteritis, we found no statistically significant or clinically relevant differences as a whole between different G or P genotypes in the severity of gastroenteritis, rated using the Ruuska-Versikari scale, or the severity of dehydration, but diarrhea lasted about two days less with G3 than either G alone or mixed types. However, these conclusions are based on some very small subgroups of rotavirus types, and this must be borne in mind, together with the wide coefficient of variation of the clinical characteristics of rotavirus gastroenteritis. Larger, adequately powered longitudinal studies are needed to examine any possible relationships between the clinical profile of rotavirus acute gastroenteritis and G and P types.

In conclusion, the present study confirms the current burden of rotavirus gastroenteritis in younger children, especially small infants, and shows up the diversity of rotavirus strains circulating in Milan and neighboring areas Continuous prospective monitoring of circulating strains may be desirable to detect any change in the distribution of rotavirus strains promptly and to assess the effectiveness of active immunization programs.

Silvia Arlati, Simonetta Cherubini, Alessandra Crimmi, Alfredo Gamboni, and Gabriella Piacentini collaborated in conducting the study.

We are grateful to all children and their families, whose participation allowed to conduct the study.

This study was funded by a grant of Regione Lombardia through the ASL Milano (Decreto n°15131, 21/12/2006)

Affiliations

1. Department of Paediatrics, Luigi Sacco Hospital, Università di Milano, Milan, Italy
   • Gianvincenzo Zuccotti
   • , Fabio Meneghin
   • , Dario Dilillo
   •  & Cecilia Mantegazza
2. Department of Public Health, Microbiology and Virology, Università di Milano, Milan, Italy
   • Luisa Romanò
   • , Sara Paladini
   •  & Alessandro Zanetti
3. Department of Paediatrics, "Guido Salvini" Hospital, Garbagnate Milanese, Italy
   • Roberta Bottone
   •  & Roberto Giacchino
4. Department of Paediatrics, Ospedale di Desio, Desio, Italy
   • Roberto Besana
   •  & Massimo Andreotti
5. Department of Paediatrics, Ospedale di Sesto San Giovanni, Sesto San Giovanni, Italy
   • Giuseppe Ricciardi
   •  & Nicola Altamura
6. Department of Paediatrics, Ospedale di Carate Brianza, Carate Brianza, Italy
   • Andrea Sterpa
7. Department of Paediatrics, Ospedale Provinciale di Saronno, Saronno, Italy
   • Giovanni Montrasio
8. Unit for Prevention, Hygiene and Infectious Diseases of the Health's General Office of Lombardy Region, Milan, Italy
   • Luigi Macchi
   •  & Anna Pavan
9. Department of Paediatrics and Unit of Medical Statistics, Università di Milano, San Paolo Hospital, Milan, Italy
   • Giovanni Radaelli

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Gianvincenzo Zuccotti.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

GZ, FM, DD, RB, CM, RG and RB made substantial contributions to the study conception and design, data acquisition, analysis and interpretation. LR, GR and AS helped draft the manuscript or revise it critically for important intellectual content. NA, MA, GM, LM, AP, AZ and GR gave final approval of the version to be published.

All authors have given final approval of the version to be published

Reprints and Permissions