Table 3 Evaluation of efficacy data obtained with three hand rubs according to different versions of ASTM E 1174
From: Less and less–influence of volume on hand coverage and bactericidal efficacy in hand disinfection
Product | Volume | Version of ASTM E 1174 | Mean log10-reduction | Neutralization in sampling fluid including validation | Time between end of application and sampling | Likelihood of false positive data | Meets US FDA requirements | Complete hand coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Purell Advanced Instant Hand Sanitizer | 5 ml | 1994 | 3.58* | No | No maximum | High | Yes | Likely |
2 ml | 1994 | 3.35* | No | No maximum | High | Yes | Likely | |
1.1 ml | 2006 | 1.85** | Yes | Maximum: 60 s | Very low | No | Unlikely | |
Purell Advanced Instant Hand Sanitizer Foam | 5 ml | 1994 | 3.55* | No | No maximum | High | Yes | Likely |
2 ml | 1994 | 3.48* | No | No maximum | High | Yes | Likely | |
1.1 ml | 2006 | 1.60** | Yes | Maximum: 60 s | Very low | No | Unlikely | |
Sterillium Comfort Gel | 5 ml | 1994 | 3.12* | No | No maximum | High | Yes | Likely |
2 ml | 2006 | 2.06** | Yes | Maximum: 60 s | Very low | Yes | Likely |