Risk factors for recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis in infants: 2-year follow up in China

Background Infants with bronchiolitis have an increased risk of developing recurrent wheezing and asthma. However, the risk factors for the development of recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis remains controversial. Our study was to investigate risk factors of post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing. Methods Infants with bronchiolitis were enrolled from November 2016 through March 2017. Nasopharyngeal aspirates were obtained for detection of respiratory viruses which were analyzed by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and direct immunofluorescent assay. Serum cytokines including TSLP, IL2, IL13, TIMP-1, MMP-9, IL33, IL5, IL4, IL25, TNF- α and MIP-1α were measured by flow cytometry. Patients were followed up every 3 months for a duration of 2 years by telephone or at outpatient appointments. Results We enrolled 89 infants, of which 81 patients were successfully followed up. In total, 22.2% of patients experienced recurrent wheezing episodes. The proportion of patients with history of eczema, systemic glucocorticoid use and patients with moderate-to-severe disease were significantly higher in the recurrent wheezing group than the non-recurrent wheezing group (83.3% vs 52.4%; 66.7% vs 36.5%; 61.1% vs 33.3%, respectively, all P < 0.05); There were no significant differences between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes in the levels of TSLP, IL2, IL13, TIMP-1, MMP-9, IL33, IL5, IL4, IL25, TNF- α and MIP-1α (P > 0.05). Logistic regression analysis showed that history of eczema was an independent risk factor for post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing (odds ratio [OR] = 5.622; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.3–24.9; P = 0.023). Conclusion The incidence of recurrent wheezing among infants after contracting bronchiolitis was 22.2% during a 2-year follow-up. History of eczema was the only independent risk factor identified and no correlation was found between the specific virus and disease severity in children with post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing.


Background
Acute bronchiolitis is a common lower respiratory tract disease characterized by inflammation of the bronchioles with a diameter of 75-300 um. It is often caused by viral infection in infants under two years and symptoms include wheezing, cough, tachypnea and chest retractions. Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the most common cause of acute bronchiolitis among infants [1,2].
Recurrent wheezing is sometimes observed after acute bronchiolitis attacks [3]. Follow up data from abroad showed that the incidence of post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing is as high as 31% [4] and about 48% of patients were diagnosed with asthma at the age of 7 years old following severe RSV bronchiolitis [5]. In a follow-up study in China [6], 35.1% (26/74) of infants at 6 months of age or less with bronchiolitis had recurrent wheezing by the age of 3 years. However, the mechanism of recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis has not been elucidated, and knowledge about risk factors is still controversial.
Current research suggests that risk factors for postbronchiolitis recurrent wheezing include: allergy [7], the elevation of specific IgE level [8], family history of asthma [9], passive smoking [10], disease severity [11] and others. A large number of epidemiological and prospective studies showed that respiratory syncytial virus infection is a risk factor for recurrent wheezing or asthma after bronchiolitis [5,12,13]. Some researchers believe that rhinovirus is a more important factor for recurrent wheezing [14]. In addition, bocavirus and metapneumovirus are also associated with recurrent wheezing and asthma following bronchiolitis [13,15]. However, Bacharier et al. showed that post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing has no relation to viral pathogens [5]. In recent years, increasing attention has been paid to the relationship between cytokine level and post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing. One study showed that IL-3 can be used as a predictor of recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis [16], and some researchers believe that MIP-1 α can be used as a biomarker to predict recurrent wheezing [17]. However, no accurate biomarkers for the prediction of recurrent wheezing are currently available for infants with bronchiolitis.
It is of great significance for treatment and prevention to understand the risk factors for recurrent wheezing following bronchiolitis. However, there are few followup studies of bronchiolitis in China, and the risk factors for recurrent wheezing remain unclear. Therefore, the objective of this study was to identify potential predicting factors for post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing in infants through a two-year follow-up study.

Methods
Infants diagnosed with bronchiolitis and hospitalized at the Department of Respiratory Disease at Children's Hospital Soochow University, China, from November 2016 through March 2017, were enrolled in this cohort study. Nasopharyngeal aspirates were obtained for detecting respiratory virus and analyzed by reversetranscriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and direct immunofluorescent assay. Serum cytokines including TSLP, IL2, IL13, TIMP-1, MMP-9, IL33, IL5, IL4, IL25, TNF-α and MIP-1α were measured by flow cytometry. The patients were followed every 3 months for a duration of 2 years by telephone or at outpatient appointments.
Recurrent wheezing was defined as two or more episodes following initial bronchiolitis for two years. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the Children's Hospital Soochow University (Approval No.: 2016050). Informed consent was obtained from the parents of all children enrolled in this study.
Exclusion criteria: Neuromuscular disease, congenital airway deformity, congenital heart disease, gastroesophageal reflux disease, bronchial foreign body inhalation, primary or secondary immune deficiency or other immune-associated diseases were excluded.

Sample collection
Nasopharyngeal aspirates were obtained using a suction catheter passed through the nose into the lower part of the pharynx for detection of viruses. Peripheral venous blood (2 ml) was also collected for detection of blood routine, humoral and cellular immunity and cytokines.
Detection of seven common viruses by direct immunofluorescent assay (DFA) DFA was used to detect respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), influenza virus A (IVA), influenza virus B (IVB), parainfluenza virus (PIV) I, PIV II, PIV III, and adenovirus (ADV). All assay kits were purchased from Chemicon (USA) and all staining procedures were performed according to the manufacturer's instructions. Immunostained preparations were viewed with a fluorescence microscope (Leica 020-518.500, Germany).

Routine blood test
Peripheral venous blood (2 ml) was collected and anticoagulated with EDTA from every patient. The blood was tested by an automatic five classification hematology analyzer for white blood cell count, absolute neutrophil count, absolute lymphocyte count and absolute count of eosinophils.

Testing of humoral immunity
Detection indices: IgG, IgM and IgA. IgG and IgM were determined by transmission immunoassay, and IgA was determined by immunoturbidimetry.

Data collection
Each patient's data, including age, gender, gestational age at delivery, birth weight, feeding patterns, history of eczema, family history of asthma, exposure to smoking, and pet contact were recorded.

Follow-up of patients
After discharge from hospital, the patients were followed up every 3 months for a 2-year period by outpatient visits or telephone consultations.

Statistical analysis
SPSS version 18.0 software was used for data analysis. Distribution normality of continuous data was tested by the P-P plots methods before comparison. Data with normal distribution were represented as mean ± standard deviation (SD) and analyzed by t tests. Continuous data with non-normal distribution were represented as median (minimum-maximum) and analyzed with the Mann-Whitney U test. Categorical data were represented as frequency and analyzed with Chi square examination. Predictors of recurrent wheezing were analyzed using a stepwise logistic regression model.

Recruitment and general characteristics
The study included 89 cases (56 males and 33 females; mean age: 4.68 ± 4.37 months).

Follow-up results
A total of 81 patients were successfully followed up and eight patients were lost to follow up due to the wrong telephone number being recorded. Of the 81 infants whose parents answered the telephone interview every three months, 22 (27.2%) infants experienced one single episode and 18 (22.2%) infants experienced recurrent wheezing, including 3(3.7%) with 2 episodes, 15 (18.5%) with ≥3 episodes. (Fig. 1).

Baseline data between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes
History of eczema was more common in patients with recurrent wheezing episodes (P = 0.037, continuity correction). There were no significant differences between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes with regards to sex, age, premature birth, feeding patterns, family history of asthma and others (P > 0.05) ( Table 3).

Clinical characteristics between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes
There were no significant differences between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes with regards to fever, feeding difficulty, chest retractions and other clinical characteristics (P > 0.05); however, the proportion of patients with moderate to severe conditions in the recurrent wheezing group was higher than that in patients without recurrent wheezing (P = 0.033) ( Table 4).

Treatment and course of disease between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes
Systemic glucocorticoid treatment was higher in patients with recurrent wheezing episodes than those without wheezing episodes (P = 0.031, continuity correction). (Systemic glucocorticoid was used during hospitalization for the first attack). There were no significant differences in the need for oxygen treatment, length of hospital stay and the length of illness between children with and without recurrent wheezing episodes (P > 0.05) ( Table 5).

Laboratory examinations between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes
There were no significant differences between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes in blood  cell count, humoral immunity, cellular immunity, serum total Ig E and antigen-specific Ig E (P > 0.05) ( Table 6).

Analysis of risk factors of recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis
We used single factor analysis to evaluate the statistically significant or near significant variables (history of eczema, systemic glucocorticoid treatment, moderate to severe condition, IL-25). By logistic multivariable regression analysis, history of eczema was identified as potential risk factor for recurrent wheezing with an OR (95% CI) of 5.622 (1.3,24.9); P < 0.05 (Table 8).

Discussion
In this study, 49.4% of the infants had at least one wheezing episode, and 22.2% of infants had experienced recurrent wheezing during the 2-year follow-up period. Several previous studies reported that the incidence of recurrent wheezing in infants with bronchiolitis was about 16-60% [3-6, 17, 19-22]. Zhang X et al. [6] followed up 74 Chinese infants who were hospitalized for bronchiolitis until the age of 3 years and found that 35.1% of the infants had recurrent wheezing. Another 1.5-year follow-up study [20] showed the prevalence of post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing among infants was 19.4%. In previous studies, allergy, antigen-specific Ig E, family history of asthma, exposure to smoking, severity of disease and specific pathogens or serum level of cytokines were found to be risk factors for recurrent wheezing [7,[9][10][11]13]. Asthmatic diseases often occur in individuals with allergic or atopic constitution, and allergic diseases may have similar pathogenesis [23]. Children with allergic  constitution are more susceptible to severe RSV infection and have a higher risk of developing airway hyperresponsiveness [24]. In a case-control study [7], it was found that 48% of children had recurrent wheezing, and allergic constitution was considered to be a risk factor. It has been reported that allergy has the strongest correlation with eczema before the age of 1 year old [25]. Several studies have shown that recurrent wheezing in infants is related to allergic dermatitis (eczema) [26,27]. Dumas et al. [28] analyzed the prospective data of 921 hospitalized children with bronchiolitis in 17 centers in the United States, and found that the risk of recurrent wheezing was significantly increased in children with eczema. It has been confirmed that eosinophils play a key role in the pathogenesis and development of atopic diseases including asthma and eczema [29,30]. Accordingly, one study [31] reported that recurrent wheezing at 36 months after bronchiolitis in infants was associated with eosinophilia. In our study, the proportion of infants with history of eczema in the recurrent wheezing group was 83.3%, which was significantly higher than in the non-recurrent wheezing group. Multivariate regression analysis suggested that history of eczema was the only independent risk factor for recurrent wheezing post bronchiolitis. Therefore, it is suggested that early intervention should be carried out in infants with  bronchiolitis accompanied by eczema in order to reduce the incidence of recurrent wheezing. Several prior studies have reported that RSV infection in early life may have a profound impact on the development of recurrent wheezing and/or asthma [5,13,32]. Other studies demonstrated that hRV-related bronchiolitis may be associated with an increased prevalence of recurrent wheezing and asthma in later childhood [9,33]. However, studies by teeratakulpisan et al. [19] and Valkonen et al. [34] found no consistent relationship between the type of virus and recurrent wheezing. In our study, 44.4% of infants were infected with RSV and 3.7% were infected with hRV. The RSV rate was lower with respect to the above studies which may be related to the test method (DFA) being associated with variable and lower sensitivity compared with PCR. We found there was no significant difference in terms of the causative virus and recurrent wheezing after bronchiolitis. As such, we suggest that further study is required to ascertain whether type of virus can be used as a predictor of recurrent wheezing.
Two demographically and clinically important differences were observed in our study between the two groups, namely, the percentage of infants with moderate to severe bronchiolitis and the usage of systemic glucocorticoids were significantly higher in infants with recurrent wheezing. A longitudinal study [11] found that in 343 children with bronchiolitis caused by RSV, the severity of the disease could be used as a predictor of asthma and atopic diseases. In addition, a 7-year followup study [35] showed that prednisolone could reduce recurrent wheezing after the first rhinovirus infection while another study [36] showed that dexamethasone could not reduce post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing 1 year later. Our study did not find that severe bronchiolitis or the usage of systemic glucocorticoids was a risk factor for recurrent wheezing, which is different from other studies. This may be related to the small sample size and/or the inclusion of less severe cases.
The pathogenesis of bronchiolitis is mainly related to excessive type 2 and/or deficient type 1 immune responses [37]. Plasma level of TNF-α, which originates from Th1 cytokine, has been reported to be of great significance in predicting the development of recurrent wheezing during acute bronchiolitis [38]. The serum level of IL-3, IL-4, IL-10, and IL-13, which originate from Th2 cytokine, were higher in children with RSV bronchiolitis secondary wheezing, and IL-3 can be used as a predictor of recurrent wheezing [16]. In our study, multivariate regression analysis showed that there was no significant difference in serum cytokine levels between patients with and without recurrent wheezing episodes. This may be related to the fact that we tested serum samples rather than nasopharynx aspirates.

Conclusions
In conclusion, the current study indicates the following conclusions: 1. the incidence of recurrent wheezing among infants after bronchiolitis was 22.2% across a 2year follow-up; 2. history of eczema is a significant risk factor for post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing; 3. no correlation was found between the specific virus and disease severity in children with post-bronchiolitis recurrent wheezing.  Our study has some limitations. Firstly, the sample size was small, and the follow-up time was relatively short. Secondly, we could not confirm whether parents gave reliable information in the phone interview. Thirdly, pathogen detection was not performed for every wheezing attack following bronchiolitis. Lastly, immunofluorescence assays have variable and lower sensitivity compared with PCR which may lead to a lower virus detection rate.