Table 2 Study Characteristics of the Economic Evaluation

Abimbola et al. 2012

Decision analytic model

Modelling

6 months after ART initiation

South Africa specific published literature

ICER ($/TB death averted)

One-way and probabilistic

Mortality rates, cost inputs

Per-capita South African 2012 GDP ($5,678 USD)

Adelman et al. 2017

Decision analytic model

Modelling

10 years

Parent study results, AHRI HIV clinic, published literature

ICER ($/DALY averted)

One-way

Varied model inputs based on ranges in the literature

Per-capita Ethiopian 2014 GDP ($505 USD)

Andrews et al. 2012

Decision analytic model

Modelling

Lifetime

Cape Town AIDS Cohort, unit costs from hospitals, published literature from South Africa

ICER ($/YLS)

One-way and two-way

Varied key parameters and costs

Per-capita South African 2010 GDP ($7,100 USD)

Bassett et al. 2010

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

HIV clinic data (McCord hospital)

Cost ($/TB case identified)

N/A

Subset of patients with cough at study entry

N/A

Bogdanova et al. 2019

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Finance department, medical insurance fund

Cost ($/TB case detected)

N/A

N/A

N/A

James et al. 2017

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

CENAT, National TB and Leprosy program, TB REACH

Cost ($/TB case detected)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Ji et al. 2020

Cost-effectiveness analysis; cost-utility and cost benefit analyses

Modelling

3 years

National Essential Public Health Program (NEPHS)

ICER ($/DALY gained)

One-way

Varied key parameters, and ROC curve

3 times per capita 2016 GDP ($ CNY not stated)

Jit et al. 2011

Decision analytic model

Modelling

N/A

Find and Treat program records, NICE guidelines

ICER ($/QALY gained)

One-way

Varied all key parameters

20–30,000 GBP per QALY

Jo et al. 2020

Cost analysis

Empirical

2 years

TB REACH budgets and financial reports, program data

Cost ($/TB case identified)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Karki et al. 2017

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Program expenditures and budget

Cost ($/TB case detected)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Kranzer et al. 2012

Cost analysis

Empirical

20 months

Study data and published literature

Cost ($/TB case detected)

One-way

Varied staff salaries and discount rates

N/A

Machekera et al. 2019

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

ZimACF project data

Cost ($/case diagnosed)

One-way

Varied all unit costs

N/A

Maheswaran et al. 2012

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Modelling

2 years

Published data

ICER ($/QALY)

Probabilistic

VOI used as alternative to univariate SA

Per capita 2010 SSA GNI ($2167 USD)

Murray et al. 2016

Decision analytic model

Modelling

Lifetime

Published literature

ICER ($/life year gained)

One-way, multi-way, and probabilistic

Per capita 2014 Ugandan GNI ($680 USD)

Orlando et al. 2018

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Modelling

1 year

DREAM program, Global Fund data, published literature

ICER ($/DALY averted)

One-way

Varied all key parameters

Per capita 2016 Mozambique GDP ($382 USD)

Reddy et al. 2019

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Modelling

2 and 5 years, lifetime

STAMP trial, published literature

ICER ($/Year of life saved (YLS))

One-way, multi-way

Varied all key parameters

Malawi ($750 USD); South Africa ($940 USD)

Sekandi et al. 2015

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Modelling

1.5 years

Uganda NTP, program data and published literature

ICER ($/additional TB case detected)

One-way

Varied costs and probabilities

Twice per capita 2013 Ugandan GDP ($1102 USD)

Shah et al. 2017

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Modelling

N/A

Peru NTP data, published literature

ICER ($/DALY averted)

One-way

Varied all model parameters

Per capita 2014 Peruvian GNI ($6300 USD)

Shah et al. 2009

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Program data

Cost ($/TB case diagnosed)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Shah et al. 2008

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Provincial TB and HIV/AIDS program data

Cost ($/TB case diagnosed)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Smit et al. 2017

Cost-effectiveness analysis

Empirical

1 year

Flemish Association for Respiratory Health and TB Control

ICER (Euros/TB case detected)

One-way

Varied costs and number of cases detected

N/A

Sohn et al. 2019

Cost analysis

Empirical

1 year

Asha Kalp program finance and operations data

Cost ($/TB case detected)

One-way

Top-down and bottom-up cost estimates provided

N/A

Winestsky et al. 2012

Decision analytic model

Modelling

10 years

Primary data in prisons, published literature from Russia, Tajikistan and Latvia

ICER ($/QALY gained)

One-way, selected two-way, situational analyses

Varied all key parameters, and plausible situational analyses

Varied WTP thresholds

Yoon et al. 2019

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Program data

Cost ($/TB case diagnosed)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Zhang et al. 2016

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Program data

Cost ($/TB case diagnosed)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Zishiri et al. 2014

Cost analysis

Empirical

N/A

Department of Correctional Services finance data, published literature

Cost ($/TB case identified)

One-way

Changed base-case parameters

N/A

Zwerling et al. 2015

Decision analytic model

Modelling

Lifetime (assumed 59.2 years)

Cost and operational analysis of four study sites, published literature

ICER ($/DALY averted)

One-way, two-way and probabilistic uncertainty analysis

Varied all key parameters

Per capita 2010 average SSA GDP ($1417 USD)