Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the studies included in the articles

From: MPT64 assays for the rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Author Study Study Design Reference Test Sample size Medium Method of detection
Hoel, I Hoel 2020 [16] Cross Sectional Study composite reference standard (CRS) 288 liquid ICC Staining (Dako Envision + System-HRP kit)
Kumar, C Kumar2020 [17] Cross Sectional Study Duplex PCR assay 92 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Sakashita, K Sakashita2020 [9] Cross Sectional Study bacteriologically diagnosed 80 solid ELISA
Da, S Da 2019 [18] Cross Sectional Study CRS 68 liquid ELISA
Phetsuksiri, B Phetsuksiri 2019 [10] Cross Sectional Study Culture followed by identification of MTC 151 liquid SD Bioline
Yan, Z Yan 2018 [19] Cross Sectional Study CRS 352 unclear BD OptEIAe Reagent Set B ELISA kit
Sanoussi, C Sanoussi2018 [20] Cross Sectional Study spoligotyping or PNB/catalase 327 solid SD Bioline
Jorstad, M Jorstad 2018 [21] Cross Sectional Study CRS 126 Löwenstein–Jensen medium t 1/250 dilution and Dako kit
Watanabe, P Watanabe 2018 [22] Cross Sectional Study phenotypic techniques and molecular tests(such as conventional or real-time PCR, line probe assays and in-house (PCR and restriction-enzyme analysis) PRA-hsp65 molecular assay) 375 liquid/solid SD Bioline
Turbawaty, D Turbawaty 2017 [23] Cross Sectional Study acid-fast bacilli and mycobacterial culture 141 liquid ICT
Kandhakumari, G Kandhakumari 2017 [24] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 75 solid BD MGIT TBcID
Kandhakumari, G Kandhakumari 2017 [24] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 75 solid SD Bioline
Orikiriza, P Orikiriza 2017 [25] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing of mycobacteria 188 liquid SD Bioline
Nerurkar, V Nerurkar 2016 [26] Cross Sectional Study Culturing of mycobacteria 1093 liquid SD Bioline
Kumar, N Kumar 2015 [8] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Molecular method(PNB inhibition test) 484 Solid/liquid SD Bioline/BD MGIT/Capilia TB
Ji, M Ji 2014 [27] Cross Sectional Study Culturing of mycobacteria 504 liquid ELISA
Zhu, Ca Zhu 2013 [28] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 328 solid ELISA
Zhu, Ca Zhu 2013 [28] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 160 solid ELISA
Hopprich, R Hopprich 2012 [29] Cross Sectional Study Molecular method +Biochemistry method 200 liquid SD Bioline
Kanade, S Kanade 2012 [30] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 150 solid SD Bioline
Roberts, S Roberts 2012 [31] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 83 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Singh, A Singh 2012 [32] Cross Sectional Study Culturing 161 liquid SD Bioline
Martin, A Martin 2011 [33] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 131 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Marzouk, M Marzouk 2011 [34] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 238 Solid/liquid SD Bioline
Ang, C Ang 2011 [35] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 294 Solid/liquid SD Bioline
Yu, M Yu 2011 [36] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 210 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Purohit, M Purohit 2007 [37] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 203 solid DakoCytomation
Mustafa, T Mustafa 2006 [38] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 55 liquid NA
Hirano, K Hirano 2004 [39] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 545 liquid Capilia TB
Hasegawa, N. Hasegawa 2002 [40] Cross Sectional Study molecular method or Biochemistry method 304 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Abe, C Abe 1999 [41] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 108 liquid NA
Gomathi, N Gomathi 2012 [11] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 346 Liquid Capilia TB
Maurya, A Maurya 2012 [42] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 150 Liquid SD Bioline
Povazan, A Povazan 2012 [43] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 123 Liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Barouni, A S Barouni, A S 2012 [44] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 161 Liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Cojocaru, Elena Cojocaru 2012 [45] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 47 Liquid/Solid SD Bioline
Brent, A Brent 2011 [46] Cross Sectional Study molecular method 208 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Gaillard, T Gaillard 2011 [47] Cross Sectional Study molecular techniques 349 solid/liquid SD Bioline
Gaillard, T Gaillard 2011 [47] Cross Sectional Study molecular techniques 349 solid/liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Lu, P Lu 2011 [48] Cross Sectional Study immunochromatographic assay 291 Löwenstein–Jensen medium/liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Said, H Said 2011 [49] Cross Sectional Study molecular assays 225 liquid BD MGIT TBcID
Toihir, A Toihir 2011 [50] Cross Sectional Study standard biochemical detection 171 Löwenstein–Jensen medium SD Bioline
Muyoyeta, M Muyoyeta 2010 [51] Cross Sectional Study phenotypic, biochemical, and molecular techniques. 623 solid/liquid Capilia TB
Hillemann, D Hillemann 2005 [52] Cross Sectional Study Molecular method 172 Liquid/Solid Capilia TB
Wang, J Wang 2007 [53] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 242 Liquid Capilia TB
Ismail, N Ismail 2009 [54] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 96 Liquid SD Bioline
Ngamlert K Ngamlert 2009 [55] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 247 Liquid Capilia TB
Shen, G Shen 2009 [56] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method/Culturing 233 Liquid Capilia TB
Chihota, V Chihota 2010 [57] Cross Sectional Study Biochemistry method 340 Liquid/Solid Capilia TB
  1. CRS Composite reference standard, MTC Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex, PNB ParaNitrobenzoic Acid
  2. a328 were serum samples, 160 from patients with definite pulmonary tuberculosis