Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the studies included in the articles

From: MPT64 assays for the rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Author

Study

Study Design

Reference Test

Sample size

Medium

Method of detection

Hoel, I

Hoel 2020 [16]

Cross Sectional Study

composite reference standard (CRS)

288

liquid

ICC Staining (Dako Envision + System-HRP kit)

Kumar, C

Kumar2020 [17]

Cross Sectional Study

Duplex PCR assay

92

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Sakashita, K

Sakashita2020 [9]

Cross Sectional Study

bacteriologically diagnosed

80

solid

ELISA

Da, S

Da 2019 [18]

Cross Sectional Study

CRS

68

liquid

ELISA

Phetsuksiri, B

Phetsuksiri 2019 [10]

Cross Sectional Study

Culture followed by identification of MTC

151

liquid

SD Bioline

Yan, Z

Yan 2018 [19]

Cross Sectional Study

CRS

352

unclear

BD OptEIAe Reagent Set B ELISA kit

Sanoussi, C

Sanoussi2018 [20]

Cross Sectional Study

spoligotyping or PNB/catalase

327

solid

SD Bioline

Jorstad, M

Jorstad 2018 [21]

Cross Sectional Study

CRS

126

Löwenstein–Jensen medium

t 1/250 dilution and Dako kit

Watanabe, P

Watanabe 2018 [22]

Cross Sectional Study

phenotypic techniques and molecular tests(such as conventional or real-time PCR, line probe assays and in-house (PCR and restriction-enzyme analysis) PRA-hsp65 molecular assay)

375

liquid/solid

SD Bioline

Turbawaty, D

Turbawaty 2017 [23]

Cross Sectional Study

acid-fast bacilli and mycobacterial culture

141

liquid

ICT

Kandhakumari, G

Kandhakumari 2017 [24]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

75

solid

BD MGIT TBcID

Kandhakumari, G

Kandhakumari 2017 [24]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

75

solid

SD Bioline

Orikiriza, P

Orikiriza 2017 [25]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing of mycobacteria

188

liquid

SD Bioline

Nerurkar, V

Nerurkar 2016 [26]

Cross Sectional Study

Culturing of mycobacteria

1093

liquid

SD Bioline

Kumar, N

Kumar 2015 [8]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Molecular method(PNB inhibition test)

484

Solid/liquid

SD Bioline/BD MGIT/Capilia TB

Ji, M

Ji 2014 [27]

Cross Sectional Study

Culturing of mycobacteria

504

liquid

ELISA

Zhu, Ca

Zhu 2013 [28]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

328

solid

ELISA

Zhu, Ca

Zhu 2013 [28]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

160

solid

ELISA

Hopprich, R

Hopprich 2012 [29]

Cross Sectional Study

Molecular method +Biochemistry method

200

liquid

SD Bioline

Kanade, S

Kanade 2012 [30]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

150

solid

SD Bioline

Roberts, S

Roberts 2012 [31]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

83

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Singh, A

Singh 2012 [32]

Cross Sectional Study

Culturing

161

liquid

SD Bioline

Martin, A

Martin 2011 [33]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

131

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Marzouk, M

Marzouk 2011 [34]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

238

Solid/liquid

SD Bioline

Ang, C

Ang 2011 [35]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

294

Solid/liquid

SD Bioline

Yu, M

Yu 2011 [36]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

210

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Purohit, M

Purohit 2007 [37]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

203

solid

DakoCytomation

Mustafa, T

Mustafa 2006 [38]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

55

liquid

NA

Hirano, K

Hirano 2004 [39]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

545

liquid

Capilia TB

Hasegawa, N.

Hasegawa 2002 [40]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method or Biochemistry method

304

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Abe, C

Abe 1999 [41]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

108

liquid

NA

Gomathi, N

Gomathi 2012 [11]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

346

Liquid

Capilia TB

Maurya, A

Maurya 2012 [42]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

150

Liquid

SD Bioline

Povazan, A

Povazan 2012 [43]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

123

Liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Barouni, A S

Barouni, A S 2012 [44]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

161

Liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Cojocaru, Elena

Cojocaru 2012 [45]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

47

Liquid/Solid

SD Bioline

Brent, A

Brent 2011 [46]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular method

208

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Gaillard, T

Gaillard 2011 [47]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular techniques

349

solid/liquid

SD Bioline

Gaillard, T

Gaillard 2011 [47]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular techniques

349

solid/liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Lu, P

Lu 2011 [48]

Cross Sectional Study

immunochromatographic assay

291

Löwenstein–Jensen medium/liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Said, H

Said 2011 [49]

Cross Sectional Study

molecular assays

225

liquid

BD MGIT TBcID

Toihir, A

Toihir 2011 [50]

Cross Sectional Study

standard biochemical detection

171

Löwenstein–Jensen medium

SD Bioline

Muyoyeta, M

Muyoyeta 2010 [51]

Cross Sectional Study

phenotypic, biochemical, and molecular techniques.

623

solid/liquid

Capilia TB

Hillemann, D

Hillemann 2005 [52]

Cross Sectional Study

Molecular method

172

Liquid/Solid

Capilia TB

Wang, J

Wang 2007 [53]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

242

Liquid

Capilia TB

Ismail, N

Ismail 2009 [54]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

96

Liquid

SD Bioline

Ngamlert K

Ngamlert 2009 [55]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

247

Liquid

Capilia TB

Shen, G

Shen 2009 [56]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method/Culturing

233

Liquid

Capilia TB

Chihota, V

Chihota 2010 [57]

Cross Sectional Study

Biochemistry method

340

Liquid/Solid

Capilia TB

  1. CRS Composite reference standard, MTC Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex, PNB ParaNitrobenzoic Acid
  2. a328 were serum samples, 160 from patients with definite pulmonary tuberculosis