Skip to main content

Table 5 Performance characteristics of the three tests in Bafia HD. Summary of sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV for microscopy, actin-qPCR and O-150 LAMP at different time points following direct observed treatment of microfilaridermic individuals with ivermectin in Bafia health district

From: Differential susceptibility of Onchocerca volvulus microfilaria to ivermectin in two areas of contrasting history of mass drug administration in Cameroon: relevance of microscopy and molecular techniques for the monitoring of skin microfilarial repopulation within six months of direct observed treatment

METHODS

SENSITIVITY

SPECIFICITY

PPV

NPV

D30

 MICROSCOPY

89.6 (61.6–99.9)

99.3 (93.0–100)

97.6 (76.9–100)

96.9 (86.2–100)

 REAL-TIME PCR

89.6 (64.5–99.6)

96.8 (87.5–99.9)

89.6 (62.2–99.7)

96.8 (87.2–99.9)

 LAMP ASSAY

97.6 (78.7–100)

92.1 (80.6–98.8)

79.0 (53.2–97.1)

99.2 (91.9–100)

D90

 MICROSCOPY

71.4 (45.8–91.8)

96.9 (88.0–99.8)

90.6 (67.0–99.5)

88.8 (74.8–97.3)

 REAL-TIME PCR

97.5 (75.8–100)

97.0 (86.3–100)

93.2 (69.3–99.9)

98.9 (87.8–100)

 LAMP ASSAY

97.5 (79.0–100)

88.7 (75.0–97.6)

78.6 (54.5–95.7)

98.8 (89.1–100)

D180

 MICROSCOPY

80.6 (62.9–93.1)

94.8 (81.3–99.6)

94.9 (80.6–99.6)

80.8 (61.5–93.4)

 REAL-TIME PCR

98.9 (87.3–100)

98.5 (84.6–100)

98.8 (86.4–100)

98.7 (83.4–100)

 LAMP ASSAY

99.0 (90.1–100)

76.6 (56.3–91.6)

83.4 (66.9–94.3)

98.6 (85.2–100)

D30 + D90 + D180

 MICROSCOPY

80.7 (68.4–90.2)

97.4 (93.1–99.5)

94.5 (85.1–98.9)

90.3 (83.1–95.2)

 REAL-TIME PCR

98.1 (90.0–100)

97.6 (92.7–99.8)

95.7 (87.1–99.6)

99.0 (94.2–100)

 LAMP ASSAY

99.4 (93.4–100)

87.1 (79.4–93.1)

80.7 (69.6–89.9)

99.6 (95.8–100)