Skip to main content

Table 2 Intended healthcare utilization among survey respondentsa versus actual healthcare utilization among patients for common infectious syndromes — South Africa, 2012

From: Responses to hypothetical health scenarios overestimate healthcare utilization for common infectious syndromes: a cross-sectional survey, South Africa, 2012

First provider consulted for illness

ILI

Pneumonia

Chronic respiratory

Meningitis

Diarrhea in child <5y

n (%)b

Intended, n = 172

Actual, n = 268

P

Intended, n = 172

Actual, n = 231

P

Intended, n = 187

Actual, n = 16

P

Intended, n = 186

Actual, n = 21

P

Intended, n = 182

Actual, n = 41

P

Would not /did not seek care

(0)

55 (21)

<.01

0

34 (15)

<.01

0

1 (6)

ns

1 (1)

0

ns

2 (1)

9 (22)

ns

Would seek / sought care

170 (99)

213 (79)

<.01

172 (100)

197 (85)

<.01

187 (100)

15 (94)

0.01

185 (99)

21 (100)

ns

180 (99)

32 (78)

<.01

Licensed medical provider

168 (98)

147 (55)

<.01

171 (99)

151 (65)

<.01

187 (100)

15 (94)

0.01

181 (97)

20 (95)

ns

177 (97)

27 (66)

<.01

Public clinic or health center

133 (77)

90 (34)

<.01

122 (71)

98 (42)

<.01

139 (74)

9 (56)

0.1

133 (72)

12 (57)

ns

146 (80)

20 (49)

0.06

Private clinic

19 (11)

9 (3)

<.01

19 (11)

8 (3)

<.01

14 (7)

0

ns

18 (10)

0

ns

17 (9)

2 (5)

<.01

Public hospital

11 (6)

5 (2)

ns

24 (14)

14 (6)

<.01

28 (15)

5 (31)

0.1

21 (11)

7 (33)

0.01

9 (5)

0

ns

Private hospital

3 (2)

9 (3)

ns

4 (2)

7 (3)

ns

4 (2)

0

1

6 (3)

0

ns

2 (1)

0

ns

Private Doctor

2 (1)

34 (13)

<.01

2 (1)

24 (10)

<.01

2 (1)

1 (6)

ns

3 (2)

1 (5)

ns

3 (2)

5 (12)

ns

Other provider

2 (1)

66 (25)

<.01

1 (1)

46 (20)

<.01

0 (0)

0

0.01

4 (2)

1 (5)

ns

3 (2)

5 (12)

0.007

Pharmacy

2 (1)

59 (22)

<.01

(0)

43 (19)

<.01

(0)

0

0.01

3 (2)

0

ns

3 (2)

2 (5)

0.007

Traditional healer

(0)

1

ns

1 (1)

1

ns

(0)

0

0.1

(0)

0

ns

(0)

1 (2)

ns

Religious leader

(0)

0

ns

(0)

1

ns

(0)

0

ns

(0)

0

ns

(0)

0

ns

Friend or relative

(0)

4 (1)

ns

(0)

0

ns

(0)

0

0.1

(0)

1 (5)

ns

(0)

1 (2)

ns

Health volunteer

(0)

1

ns

(0)

1

ns

(0)

0

1

(0)

0

ns

(0)

0

ns

Other

(0)

1

ns

(0)

0

ns

(0)

0

ns

1 (1)

0

ns

(0)

1 (2)

ns

  1. aFor each infectious syndrome, respondents who reported an actual episode of the infectious syndrome within the household were excluded from the analysis of intended healthcare utilization
  2. bExcludes episodes of ILI (1), pneumonia (4), chronic respiratory illness (1), meningitis (1), and diarrhea (1) for which the first provider consulted was unknown
  3. P-values greater than 0.1 are indicated with “ns”